PDA

View Full Version : [OT] A friend needs advice



SilentEye
26-06-04, 11:27
Hey,

I have a friend here, who tried to post a little problem on one of those immature forums, of course you can understand how that turned out, much swearing.

I told her I could post it here for her because I was sure that the answers here would be mature, and would help.
So don't let me down boys :)

Don't be afraid to read a little text dudes.
Here's the message:

I need advice. For the sake of privacy reasons, I'll exclude names and just try to be as clear as I possibly can.

I have a good friend, whose friendship I am in danger of losing. She's going through rough times. Her mother and father are getting a divorce because he was having an affair. She's also trying to keep up with her college work. Her main problem, though, is that she's got muddled feelings for this guy. He's been a friend of hers for years and now he's in love with her. She knows about his feelings, but she doesn't know how she feels about him. Yet when she's with him, its obvious she's happy. I can understand why. Out of all of the guys she's been with, he's the only one who is willing to go places and do things with her, buy things for her, and treat her like she should be treated. One thing that gets me is that he's possessive. When a mutual friend of ours told him that her mother didn't want her to be coming home late all the time, he responded "Well, she's just going to have to get used to (my friend) coming home late." Majorly wrong.

The problem is, though, that she doesn't know her feelings for him, and yet she's sleeping with him, fooling around with him, and, from my point of view and that of others, leading him on in thinking that she loves him as much as he loves her. She lets him cling to her like velcro and she does the same in kind. In most of the group activities we do lately, when our friends are together, she brings him along. No matter where we go, eventually his face will turn up. She's also been blowing off her friends to be with him. One incident, as an example, was that another friend and I had gone out to get something to eat and visit another friend because he was depressed. We called them and told them to come down. They never did. They kept calling and saying they'd be there shortly, but never came. I hear later that he (the guy she's confused over) kept saying he didn't want to go and refused to get up. He was her only transportation at the time. I can drive, but she never called me to come pick her up. She just let him keep her there. This was an example of his possessiveness and, in my opinion, manipulation. She's letting him do it, too. So, you can imagine that I REALLY don't like him. Admittedly, he's the best guy she's ever been with, but his possessiveness is a real turn-off.

So while I fumed internally, I despised him more and more. I got a bit jealous. I became more enraged at the fact that she's sleeping with him, but can't even define her feelings for him. The fact that she includes him in nearly everything we do now also makes me fume. Sometimes we just want it between friends, meaning excluding the boyfriend person. Whenever he shows up, the evening just seems to die right then and there. All of our friends know that when he shows up, things just go bad. Nothing goes as planned, things get changed, and they are all over each other while the rest of us just sit and watch. Of course, we never brought it up what we were thinking, seeing, and feeling.

A couple days ago she came online. She never does that except when things are bad or she has bad news. Sure enough, she asked me the wrong question. She asked me what grudge I had against this guy. I was still fuming about the fact that she had wanted to include him in plans that we had made months ago, which never included him and I never planned them to, so when she asked me that question, I blew up. I exploded and let out all of my feelings, while still being somewhat rational. I mentioned everything that I saw, well except for the part about her sleeping with him. She got angry. We argued. She went offline for a while, then came back and we talked a little more rationally. Then, it just went bad again. I haven't seen her or spoken to her since that night. So, I'm worried that she's angry with me to the point that she won't speak with me.

I fee like a heel for hurting her feelings, but I know what I said was right. Still, despite that, I feel bad for arguing with her. Now I feel dead inside from the rush of negative emotions that come in waves from time to time. I'm at a complete loss and I just don't know what to do. I don't know if I should call her or go to her house and face her. I don't know if I can do that just yet. I've got a nother friend of ours trying to encourage me to face her, but I'm scared to. I'm worried that our friendship has fallen completely. I don't want her to be angry with me and I don't want to be angry with her. Its just that, at this point, I'm at a total loss of what I should do. There are things that sound right, but I still don't know. I'm stuck.

So, that's my problem. I'm stuck and I need help from other POV's. Also, I have to ask, would you do what she's doing? Would you lead someone on like that when you still can't decide on how you feel for them? Would you sleep with them and fool around with them if you were so confused? It just doesn't seem right to me.

I feel like crying, but I can't. I just know that I can't solve this by myself. Please, please help me.

spongeb0b
26-06-04, 11:48
It seems to me like she's stuck in a rut, she's so used to him being there and giving her all the attention that she seeks (as we all need) that she has become stuck in routine. She's scared that if she lets this person go, then there will be no one else for her.

I understand how angry and upset you must be, and it must hurt you to see how her life is going.

I think personally, just give her a call, and have a chat, tell her that you are worried about her, and that it is nothing to do with the fact that you dislike him, but that you care. Tell her that from your point of view, she must be hurting herself to be like this with him, and that she needs to have a good long think about what will make HER happy. And of course that if she needs someone to talk to about it, you will always be there (as im sure you already feel)

Sometimes people become so stuck into a routine that you are scared to let go.

If the chat goes ok, suggest you meet up ON YOUR OWN with her.

Stress that you only want to see that she is totally happy in herself in the situation. Because at the end of the day, all the decisions that we make about our own lifes have to be to make ourselves happy.

-DarknessFairy-
(borrowing bob's account cos i cant be bothered to log into my own)

ps im a girl :p

cRazy2003
26-06-04, 12:14
[ edited ]

retr0n
26-06-04, 14:51
Off Topic:


Her main problem, though, is that she's got muddled feelings for this guy. He's been a friend of hers for years and now he's in love with her. She knows about his feelings, but she doesn't know how she feels about him. Yet when she's with him, its obvious she's happy. I can understand why. Out of all of the guys she's been with, he's the only one who is willing to go places and do things with her, buy things for her, and treat her like she should be treated.

That's my damn story!! Only i'm the guy :confused:



Back on topic though:


I had the same kinda thing happend to me, well not exactly the same, but
almost, my friends girlfriend was very very possesive and even though she
was a nice person to hang out with and all she would never let him do
anything with his guy-friends only.

She never allowed him to come with us to a pub or anything if she wasn't
invited. Granted she was invited most of the time and is a cool person it's
just not the same. Sometimes we just wanted to have a guys-only-night-out,
not that he would try to pick up another girl or anything but she never had
any trust in him.

As time passed and he kept blowing us off more and more often we kinda
got a little pissed at him and her, well mostly her. After some time though
we all realized that it wasnt her fault, it's his. If he is willing to put up with
that and blow all of his friends off just because she can't stand him doing
anything without her being involved then it's his choice.

Basicly what i'm saying is even though this guy may be a jerk or whatever
it's still her that's allowing him to be so. Now that you explained how you
feel about him it's only natural for her to get a little pissed. What you need
to do is just sit down and have a cup of coffe and explain yourself a little
bit better, more rational so to say. Use better phrasing and so on.

The longer you wait the harder it's going to get, it's best to deal with it
straight off and if it doesnt work out then you atleast tried. But it's no
use in letting a friendship just go bad because you were afraid of confronting
her.


:p

P.S. I'm back :D

- Primate

greendonkeyuk
26-06-04, 15:12
didnt read previous povs... sorry, sounds to me like you like this girl more than a friend, maybe you jus didnt admit it to yourself yet thats all? sounds like youd be a better boyfriend to her than this other guy would anyhow.

i think she needs to tell the guy to back off, if he truly respects her then he should respect everything about her and be her friend first then her lover 2nd. if not hes a selfish bastard and she shouldnt go near him. its all good to treat people nice and say nice things to them and all that, some guys do it jus to get into bed with a girl. I hope this dude aint one of those guys and if not then he needs to learn to share her. she has friends too (you and your other mates) and i presume shes known all of you for longer than shes known him. in any case no one person has the rights to dictate what another person does or says or where they go. if you truly dont like the guy then tell her that, dont beat around the bush, jus come right out and say it. honesty is BY FAR the best course of action in my book. all the girls ive ever been with (relationships/flings/summer romances) ive always been honest with, even if sometimes ive said something they didnt want to hear. A relationship has to be built on trust and respect and honesty. Bottom line. Without that its just an extended porn movie.

Regards to the problems with her family etc, well she needs people like you about now for support with all that stuff. It sounds like you guys are close and if so then she should know that youre there for her, dont push her into talking about stuff but let her know youre there if she needs you and more importantly when she needs you.

Its a tough break seeing your folks split, ive had 13 years to get over mine but it still pangs from time to time. However i was a kid then and im an adult now so i look at things differently, most importantly i had people around me who loved me and cared for me and they were the most important part as they helped me get through it all.

I hope ive covered all your points bud.

hope it all works out.

OpTi
26-06-04, 15:29
sounds to me like they are both as bad as eachother and if she is unwilling to see or ever hear your point of view then screw it. He's possesive and she's leading him on, the situation is coming inbetween friendships NOTHING & NOBODY should come between long term friends, afterall if that persons gone and you fucked off all your friends who you gonna turn to then?

if it was my friend i'd confront them in person and say how i felt if they refuse to listen i'd walk out and never call again but thats just me, i don't chase after people who claim to be my friends then refuse to acknowledge my feelings. Especialy when i put the effort in to explain my feelings and attempt to resolve the problem.

probably sounds harsh but it's better going to them now and trying to sort it at least it shows you care, you should at least get the same curtosy back if you don't then you know where you and probably all of her other friends stand.

wench
26-06-04, 15:39
My sympathies go out to you, I had my best friend do a similar thing, and over time he closed her down not allowing her to go anywhere without him. If he was working away he was ringing her making accusations and being generally controlling. I had to watch her destroy herself on this guy and become a shadow of the person I knew within 6 months of meeting him. Unfortunately she believed he was her soulmate. It took her 8 years to find the strength to turn herself around, and ask him to leave her life.

No one was allowed near her, so we all stood by and waited for the day that she was ready to ask for help. When she asked we were all there. It wasn’t easy but she had to make her own mistakes and find her own lessons. I had my own life to lead and so did she. Whenever she asked my advice I was always honest with her, and she respected that honesty. I never coated things in sugar to make her feel better about her decisions and I never attacked her about them either.

It would seem this guy is being allowed to affect your friendship, by both of you, the decision needs to be made how important your friendship is. I feel it may be unfair of you to vent your frustration on her, Your problem ultimately seems to be with him. I would be inclined to treat her the way you have always treated her, and pretty much ignore him, after all is he really that important that he deserves so much of your attention ?

If you feel the need to make an apology then do so but if you felt your comments were true, then apologise for hurting her feelings, not for what was said.

Trust in the strength of your friendship.

Organics
27-06-04, 19:48
Hey,
Her main problem, though, is that she's got muddled feelings for this guy. He's in love with her. She knows about his feelings, but she doesn't know how she feels about him. Yet when she's with him, its obvious she's happy. I can understand why. Out of all of the guys she's been with, he's the only one who is willing to go places and do things with her, buy things for her, and treat her like she should be treated.



Disturbing. That's almost my exact situation described above, in this case, I'm the guy but there's no possessiveness. Bah, relationships are nasty creatures at times.

As for your friend though, if she's unwilling to listen, no matter how hard you try then she's not too much of a friend?

jernau
27-06-04, 20:07
Is it me or are there a lot more of these threads lately?

It's all a bit AOL for a "dark cyberpunk world" isn't it?



Oh well - to answer the question - sounds like he's less than impartial to me and should just be honest about it.

extract
27-06-04, 22:11
first off her main problem isnt some guy like stated its her friends

the person who wrote this letter says the boy is possesive

HA!

look at her friend.....shes mad cause plans that didnt include him before do now?

she cant let her friend have a boyfriend, shes mad at her friend cause she doesnt know her feeling for him yet?

wtf is this some kind of joke?

bleh

SilentEye
27-06-04, 22:22
Extract, no.

She's mostly worries because I think she doesn't really trusts this guy, and she believes that her friend is ruining her life over this guy.

Such as being almost every minute with the dude, having sex with the dude while she's ambarresed for it her self.

There's more, but I don't want to say things wrong and get hammered.

Silent

HatchetRyda
27-06-04, 23:01
Keep personal problems your self

"Gawd" - Shaye Saint John

Lexxuk
28-06-04, 01:11
Different POV, you cant get any more different than mine :p

Seems to me that the person writting the post is insecure. His/Her friend has found a new boyfriend, but it doesnt sound possesive to me, it just sounds like two people who care for each other wanting to spend lots of time together.

Now however, you've told your friend "look, we dont like your boyfriend" but thats totally wrong, you cant say that kind of stuff, you could have talked to your friend and told her that you wanted some friend only stuff, no partners allowed. But the truth of the matter is, as people grow older, so their social circle changes, your friends social circle now includes her boyfriend. You have to learn to accept that your "group" wont always be your "group" that people and friends will move on, close friends will eventually become aquantainces or however its spelt, and that you'll meet new friends.

Just learn to live and let live, if your friend is happy with her boyfriend, then let her be happy, she's obviously going through a rough time and needs all the support she can get, not some bitchin about her boyfriend.

SilentEye
28-06-04, 01:45
That person(Lexxuk) doesn't understand that she's NOT happy.
As you see, she isn't very happy, Sara told me that she thinks she's paying the guy back by handing out services to him, mind the lack of better terms.

Also, as I said before the girl is more ashamed of what she does then happy.


S

-REMUS-
28-06-04, 02:00
Your interperation seems Jaded by your dislike of the boyfreind.

He seems like a bit of an unsensitive cock no doubt if what you say is true, best approch you can take is just speak to her in the calmest tone possible do not get baited into getting aggressive thats just an escape route for her to storm off.

Just keep them talking try to make them understand your points, you cannot do more than that appart from maybe speaking to her parents, but only do so if you think they can handle this properly.

If she is unhappy then she should end it, but I dont understand why she would be appart from the divorce, its not as if hes abuseing her, i've been in situations where my GF wants to go but i'm with freinds, usually ill just take her home and come back. So just take everything into perspective, if shes crying over the phone to you saying how unhappy she is then fair play get her out of it, get her to stay over at your house for a few days and talk it out.

There just doesnt seem to be anything wrong with whats happening, just sounds like a teenage relationship. And belive me some men abuse the word "love" all too much......

BTW: I'm real tired so if this is crap just ignore it!

NS_CHROME54
28-06-04, 02:07
that's what i like about this forum. for the most part the people on it aren't immature asses. lord knows i got lots of help here recently.

about confronting her: you'll only smoulder on the inside more and more until you do it, so there's no use in putting it off. it's best to give it a try, even if you don't know what to do.

darknessfairy
28-06-04, 14:53
I must say i am surprised that in a forum full of hormone-driven men (or boys :lol: ) that there have been some very sensible answers here...Well done guys!

ps... keep us updated how it goes... I hope its for the best

Lexxuk
28-06-04, 23:06
As you see, she isn't very happy, Sara told me that she thinks she's paying the guy back by handing out services to him, mind the lack of better terms.

Also, as I said before the girl is more ashamed of what she does then happy.


S

In that case, all you can do is sit back and wait for time to take its course, then be there for your friend when you need her. Trying to get in between her and her new boyfriend will do nothing more than push her more towards him. So wait a while, when it fizzles out, you can be there for ur mate.

-REMUS-
28-06-04, 23:23
I must say i am surprised that in a forum full of hormone-driven men (or boys :lol: ) that there have been some very sensible answers here...Well done guys!

ps... keep us updated how it goes... I hope its for the best

HEY! men can be agony aunts too, Killroy is a god!

Vampire222
28-06-04, 23:31
best would be if you talked to her about it, obviously she isnt aware of the potential damage she could cause later on